Paul Cutler's Migration Case Law Blog
Preparation #2
The case of AEK20 v Minister [2022] FCAFC 175 is another decision that demonstrates the importance of providing evidence to support claims made in applications for revocation of a character cancellation.
AEK20 moved to Australia from Samoa at age 9 in 1999. In 2012 he pleaded guilty to a murder which was committed in the course of a violent home invasion. He also gave evidence against his co-offenders.
Because he had assisted police and given evidence against the co-offenders he claimed that he feared that he would be killed if he was returned to Samoa. His ground of appeal was effectively that the court at first instance hadn’t properly considered his claim that he would be inadequately protected in Samoa.
The main reasons for dismissing his appeal were set out in [16] of the judgement:
“…..The claim is limited to a subjective fear. The appellant did not claim that he would be “unable to access effective protection if returned to Samoa”. Nor did he claim that there was no form of witness protection available to him in Samoa. Moreover, those representations were not supported by any evidence which might have enabled the Minister to engage in any comparative analysis between Samoa and Australia concerning the risk of harm to the appellant or any analysis of the nature and extent of such risk. Nor was there any evidence of any threats of harm in Samoa, or who in Samoa would seek to harm him (the offending having occurred in Australia)”.
In many respects this amounts to the Applicant didn’t discharge their onus of proof. Evidence to support submissions is important!
Creative commons acknowledgment for the photograph.
50% Fee Increase
The Department has announced a 50% increase to application fees for partner visa subclasses from 1 January 2015. PARTNER VISA CHARGES * Provisional and permanent partner visas - currently $3085 increased to $4627.50 * Prospective marriage visa - currently $3085 increased to $4627.50 * Temporary and permanent partner visas - currently $4575 increased $6865.50 Further information can be found on...
Assessment of general professional occupations
From 1 January 2015, VETASSESS is introducing a revised Skills Assessment process for general professional occupations. The Skills Assessment will include an assessment of the highest qualification level and the “date deemed skilled” based on qualification and employment evidence provided. This will offer a streamlined application process with one application form, a simpler fee structure and a...
English Tests
From 23 November 2014, IELTS is no longer the only way for proving english ability for migration purposes. Migration Regulations 1994 - Specification of Evidence of Functional English Language Proficiency, specifies the following tests and scores for demonstrating functional English: An average score of at least 4.5 in an IELTS test. A total band score of at least 32 in a TOEFL iBT test An...
Unauthorised children?
MIA News Issue 253 contained an article about UNICEF Australia's opposition to the Migration and Maritime Powers Legislation Amendment (Resolving the Asylum Legacy Caseload) Bill 2014. Along with other human rights organisations, UNICEF said the Bill attempted to remove Australia’s international obligations, reduce powers of the Australian courts and give extensive discretionary control to the...